Sun 8 Nov 2009 | You are here: Home > chatroom > Birth buddies > My baby is due in Nov 09 > Breast or Bottle?
There is a problem with your Flash Player.
left col

Where will you be doing your Xmas shopping?


Disclaimer

The material contained on these pages is in no way intended to replace professional medical care or advice and should not be used as a basis for diagnosis or choice of treatment. Answers to specific problems may not apply to everyone. If you're worried, see your GP.


Breast or Bottle?

  |<   <   1   2   >   >|  33 items
Forum Jump
Author Message

natashamaync
Joined : Feb 04, 2009
Posts : 939
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 10, 2009 10:39:07 PM
Subject : Breast or Bottle?

Hey girls,

Was just wondering what you are all planning on doing? If I am completley honest I dont really like the idea of breastfeeding - although I have promised my OH that I will do it and stick with it! As a compromise I have asked if I can breastfeed during the day and bottle feed at night time. This will also be an advantage for me as my OH never ever sleeps - days that he does he manages to drift off about 5 ish for only a few hours a night! Hes always been the same and is fine with it but will be brilliant for me as we have said if I go to sleep about 11 that means I can sleep to about 7 if he can get a feed in before he goes to sleep!!!

ANYWAY!! What are you all planning on doing?? Dont think im a terrible mother for not wanting to breastfeed!!

xx

[Modified by: natashamaync on 10 July 2009 22:41:22 ]

Back to top
d7b
Joined : Oct 27, 2008
Posts : 549
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 10, 2009 10:50:13 PM

I don't think you're a terrible mother. Breastfeeding is very personal and it isn't right for everyone. I know some friends who've tried, but it just hasn't worked. I am going to give it a go, and I'm hoping to be able to stick with it, but I don't feel pressurised into it & neither should anyone else. Neither will I feel like I've failed if it doesn't work. At the end of the day you have to do what's best for you and your baby and you won't know that until baby's here.

Hope this helps,
Dx
19+5

Back to top
natashamaync

natashamaync
Joined : Feb 04, 2009
Posts : 939
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 10, 2009 11:25:29 PM

Hey D,
Thanks for your reply. I actually really appreciate your opinion on this - as I do make myself feel guilty for not being 100% into it.
My mom swears blind that the reason she developed PND is because she carried on breast feeding as she felt forced into doing it by my father! So I will be sure to listen to myself and if im not happy thats the main thing - ill be taking on board your mindset - that you wont feel like you have failed if it doesnt work!

Thank u again honey! xx

Back to top
Mummy Chooch738

Mummy Chooch738
Joined : Jan 04, 2009
Posts : 564
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 10, 2009 11:28:06 PM

Hi,
I'm hopefully going to bf. Did it for 13 months exclusively with my lo. Wouldn't know what to do with a bottle lol! x

20+2

Back to top
natashamaync

natashamaync
Joined : Feb 04, 2009
Posts : 939
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 10, 2009 11:33:26 PM

Wow that really is brilliant! Obviously you must enjoy it - I really hope this happens for me!! xx

Back to top
gazza40
Joined : Mar 17, 2009
Posts : 36
Rank: Newbie

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 11, 2009 7:54:09 AM

Hi Tash

I'm bottlefeeding this time, my daughter was born 12 years ago (I was a young 21 year old) and gave it a go for 2 days and then stopped, she was a big baby and I certainly wasnt big, I had an awful midwife who me a failure for giving up (helps with the confidence of being a new and young mum!) I spent hours and hours on the first 2 days trying to bf and it was never enough, I couldnt get up to go to the toilet, didnt get to eat breakfast as you had to go to central room for breakfast, after the horrible midwife finished her shift I was in tears wondering how the hell I would cope and a lovely midwife came and spoke to me and my husband and said the most important thing to me ever - she was my baby and I was to do what I wanted to do as it would be me that would be looking after her and bringing her up not any of them and if bottle feeding works then do it - didnt look back and I have a beautiful, healthy, happy and intelligent 12 year old daughter, it took all the pressure off my shoulders having that discussion and made it fun for the 3 of us to be able to bond.

I am looking to do the first feed by breast just for all the collostrum (spelt wrong!) but the rest will be bottles. People may judge and criticise me but I dont care because this is my baby and for me and my family to bring up, I have living proof that it was fine first time round but it is my decision and I want to be able to enjoy the first stages with my family and allowing us all to bond in the same way. I am not in anyway against breastfeeding in anyway but it just didnt work for me. Sorry rant over just wanted to make the point after what I went through last time and to just basically say go with whatever suits you the best because at the end of the day she is your little baby girl and nobody else.

Nat x

Back to top
Rosapenny

Rosapenny
Joined : Sep 15, 2008
Posts : 2322
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 11, 2009 9:23:28 AM

I have to be honest as well and say im not comfortable with the idea of me breastfeeding at all. I know that sounds terrible but for me I just dont like the idea of breast feeding. My MIL is trying to push me into it and its just not something that I want to do at all. I also plan to do the first feed for the collestrum but after that its bottle feeding. I always have this uncomfortable notion though that people are going to be really awful about me bottle feeding.

Back to top
xxAmbersMum2bxx

xxAmbersMum2bxx
Joined : Jul 06, 2008
Posts : 3025
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 11, 2009 11:42:11 AM

Im really keen to breastfeed and really hope I can do it - but I agree with the others, it's a very personal thing what you decide to do and you shouldnt be made to do one or the other.

My MIL (along with dh's cousins) are all dead set against me breastfeeding. I dont think it's a bad thing they all bottle fed but I dont think they should be forcing their opinions onto me and trying to put me off breastfeeding if it's what I personally feel is right for me. They can be really awful about it, I just dont understand why. Plus as you know the advice is if youre breastfeeding to do it till the baby is 6 months - loads of health benefits and baby doesnt go without. MIL is dead against this as well, she thinks you should wean a baby as early as theyll start taking food!!! Im just going to ignore her - what else can I do!!!

I think that whatever you decide to do, therell always be someone ready to say you should be doing it differantly - so just do what you want/can do and ignore them. Most people wont think anything of it - and the ones that do dont matter!
xax

Back to top
sim75

sim75
Joined : Oct 04, 2008
Posts : 1233
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 11, 2009 6:55:03 PM

I hope to breastfeed, and if I can for as long as poss. But it really is a personal choice so once you have made it DONT LISTEN TO ANYONE ELSE!! (except us Happy !)

If you dont want to breastfeed then you shouldnt be forced to do it , or made to feel guilty for not choosing to do it!!! One of my friends felt really uncomfortable about it as she couldnt disassociate it from being something for her husband. Whatever the reason, it is your own personal thing. But one thing to bear in mind is that you will probably get a thrashing from the midwives as apparently they give girls a hard time for not wanting to or not trying. Just shut it all out.

xx

Back to top
bon79

bon79
Joined : Nov 22, 2007
Posts : 1869
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 12, 2009 7:07:13 PM

hi ladies, im crashing from born in june...I BF'd for 2 weeks and gave up after both I and LO got too stressed out to do it anymore. I always said whilst PG I would do it for as long as we were both happy and no longer...I ended up in pain, crying most nights and LO was feeding sometimes for over 2 hours meaning I felt tied to the house not knowing when she would next feed...
so, from my experience I would say, if you're happy to bf then do so but please don't put yourself under pressure to do it for x weeks/months...and if you're not bf'ing or have to stop for whatever reason - good on you too....after all in my opinion a happy mum and baby is THE most important thing....and you should enjoy those first weeks too - it goes so QUICKLY!!!

Back to top
Lentil
Joined : Feb 12, 2008
Posts : 413
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 12, 2009 7:33:21 PM

Natasha - the only thing I would say is that you may struggle to do the half and half thing. Once you start bottle feeding the breasts think you don't need so much milk so stop making so much. It would probably work if you can express (I'm not liking that idea myself at the moment) but you may find you don't have enough milk during the day.
I'd say give it a go - you don''t need to get out of bed at night - get your oh to bring baby to you then change the nappy after so you can go straight back to sleep. If it doesn't work for you, then go to bottles - what is best for mum is best for baby!

Back to top
EmilyB

EmilyB
Joined : Aug 17, 2008
Posts : 1219
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 13, 2009 12:17:46 AM

I'm hoping to breastfeed - I and my mum are both convinced that I'd have significantly fewer health problems if she'd been encouraged to bf me instead of being told to bottlefeed me. She breastfed my brother and he doesn't have asthma or eczema now, whereas I was a brittle asthmatic for years. I have to say I'll be devestated if I can't breastfeed, as with having such bad asthma I don't think there's any other way of helping to tip the odds in baby's favour, as the likelihood is that they will have asthma. Doc has said the best thing I can do is try breastfeeding, as it's likely to set my baby up with less risk of developing it. I'm hoping to express a bit too so hubby can feed the baby and I can have a sleep! ;)

Em 20+6 x x x

Back to top
kirstynov09
Joined : May 22, 2009
Posts : 221
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 13, 2009 7:34:35 AM

Im hoping to breat feed this time as i was made to feel uncomfotable when i had my girls by ex husband and because i was young. Im looking forward to trying it but if it doesnt work or i dont like it i wont be too fussed to bottle feed again

Back to top
*Maria*

*Maria*
Joined : Sep 22, 2008
Posts : 1429
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 13, 2009 7:51:46 AM

I really, really, really hope I can breast feed. However, if it doesn’t work out for baby or me, I won’t feel bad for using a bottle. I’m sure there are loads of women who say breast is best, but I’m guessing those are the one who had little or no problem breast feeding. My friends little boy spent the first 3 weeks of his life screaming non-stop. She was at breaking point and the poor baby just wasn’t a happy little guy. Anyway, it turns out that although she was producing milk, there wasn’t enough and her little boy was crying because he was so hungry. She changed to bottle feeding and the crying stopped instantly!

I won’t be giving up easily on breast feeding – cracked nips, bleeding etc I’ll keep trying…… However, if the baby starts to suffer I’ll stop and try bottle feeding, or maybe I could pump and then give the baby breast milk with the bottle.

I definitely don’t/ won’t judge women who chose to bottle feed, becoming a mother must be hard at the best of times so everyone needs to do what’s best for them.

M x :\)

Back to top
pavy

pavy
Joined : Nov 25, 2008
Posts : 1140
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 13, 2009 9:26:19 AM

I dont think anyone should get too stressed about it.. I really wanted to Breast feed last time but it just didn't work out and my son has not had a sick day in his whole 2 years.. Formula is very nutritious and if it came down to the fact my baby was'nt getting enough nourishment then it would defo be bottle.. My freind is a midwife and neo natal nurse and she told me some horific stories about babies ending up ill as mums wont let a drop of formula pass the babies lips, blood sugar drops and can cause brain damage if they arent fed properly.. x

Back to top
Ellie.x
Joined : Apr 30, 2009
Posts : 269
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 13, 2009 10:03:41 AM

Im going to bottle feed, although I have compromised with my OH and said i'll breast feed for the first few weeks if I can.

I was a bit worried about telling my midwife as she's quite old fashioned, but she just said that although she was there to encourage breastfeeding, it was my body and my baby and not to be pressured into doing something i didnt want to do xx

Back to top
evab1
Joined : Dec 06, 2006
Posts : 668
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 13, 2009 8:56:48 PM

Breast feeding for me. I did last time and it was great. Obviously sore initially but a little suffering is fine and so part of being a mum :) most of my friends haven't bf and I really hate when they hand me a baby and a bottle as i'm hopeless witha bottle. Don't know what i'm doing. I did express last time and lo breast fed til she was 11 months then just chose to stop. Will just see how long this one wants to go but def for 6 months. I think it's good that everyone has an idea what they're going to do but remember that once baby comes it can all change. My friend was so set on bf and couldn't do it and gave up and felt awful bout it but wasn't her fault. So take it easy on yourself and don't worry bout it either way x

Back to top
goldiemad

goldiemad
Joined : Oct 13, 2008
Posts : 874
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 14, 2009 8:13:08 AM

Dont worry natasha, Im also not overly comfortable with it and the plan is to BF during the day provided Im in the house and maybe express for the night. Im going to try it but if Im not comfortable with it then I will switch to bottle. Im not gonna beat myself up about it.
Hugs
Amy 24+2 xx

Back to top
oakland1981

oakland1981
Joined : May 21, 2009
Posts : 48
Rank: Regular

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 14, 2009 10:35:19 AM

Im not going to breastfeed. I didnt with my son and dont intend to this time either, personally I just cant get my head round it but admire those mothers who can. I was really worried that the midwife would be nasty to me for not even trying but she was ok as long as your firm and dont be bullied into anything your not comfortable with. It is the most healthy option but its important to have a healthy mother aswell who is happy with herself. Once I was firm and said no and explained my reasons the midwifes never mentioned it again. Good luck xxx

Back to top
summer76
Joined : Sep 20, 2007
Posts : 1755
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 14, 2009 11:06:46 AM

dont put any pressure on yourself - i would like to breastfeed but if i cant i wont feel guilty.

I would also love to use reusable nappies but if it is too much then disposables it will be.

What ever suits you and NOT ANYONE ELSE!!!!

x x x x

Back to top
summer76
Joined : Sep 20, 2007
Posts : 1755
Rank: Star user

My Other Topics
Posted : Jul 14, 2009 11:06:47 AM

dont put any pressure on yourself - i would like to breastfeed but if i cant i wont feel guilty.

I would also love to use reusable nappies but if it is too much then disposables it will be.

What ever suits you and NOT ANYONE ELSE!!!!

x x x x

Back to top
Forum Index -> Birth buddies -> My baby is due in Nov 09
  |<   <   1   2   >   >|  33 items


Who's online?

*Babylove* | - Nessie - | Barley81 | becci boo | Bedhead | bellah | Breighlin | BroodyBeth | Candygirl | clarehair | em7 | fiandrup | gemsie24 | HALES27 | heather1973 | joemoeuk | JunieMummy | LibbyJan10 | Lisa1611 | lollyhatch | lucylooandbabykins | madsbellsngeorge | mum2b2009 | NatashaJ | NattyNik | one plus bump | Pickle1984 | Poz | she11ey55 | Starlottie | stuckinlimbo | Trixie09 | willibelucky | woomummy |



Board statistics

We have 87625 discussion board members

Welcome to our latest member Asha V

In total there are 197 active users online, 34 members and 163 guests

CONTACT | FAQ | PRIVACY | TERMS & CONDITIONS | ADVERTISERS | TOP
The National Magazine Company Ltd. © Copyright 2008